Music.app Symlink Race Conditions Could Enable macOS TCC Bypass

Summary
Jamf Threat Labs describes two Music.app symlink race conditions that could be chained to replace macOS’s TCC database and bypass protections for sensitive data. Apple’s initial mitigation was incomplete; both issues are now patched.
Key points
- Jamf Threat Labs identified two race conditions in Music.app that could be chained to replace a user’s TCC database.
- During saved-state cleanup, a symlink race could redirect file deletion to the legitimate TCC database.
- During media import, a separate race involving file copying could redirect the operation and place an attacker-controlled database in its place.
- The chain required precise timing after a single Music.app launch and could enable access to TCC-protected data.
- Apple’s macOS Sonoma 14.4 fix for CVE-2024-23285 reduced the impact but did not resolve the underlying race conditions.
- The remaining issue was fixed under CVE-2026-86933; the article says both vulnerabilities are patched and recommends updating Mac fleets.
Article Details
- Attack Vectors
- An attacker could exploit a symlink race condition in Music.app's saved-state cleanup to redirect deletion and remove the user's TCC database.
- A second symlink race condition in Music.app's media-import workflow could redirect the clonefile() operation, allowing an attacker to place a database with attacker-chosen permissions where the legitimate TCC database had been.
- The reported exploit chain required precise timing after a single Music.app launch and combined deletion of the legitimate TCC database with its replacement, enabling unauthorized access to TCC-protected data.
- Defensive Notes
- Both vulnerabilities are patched. Administrators should ensure their macOS fleets receive updates containing the fixes.
- Apple's initial mitigation in macOS Sonoma 14.4 reduced the vulnerabilities' maximum impact but did not resolve the underlying race conditions; the remaining issue was later fixed in macOS under CVE-2026-86933.
- The article recommends layered defenses, including permission controls, endpoint protection, and the ability to detect and respond to malicious activity.
MITRE ATT&CK
CVE
CVE-2024-23285Apple · macOSBoth vulnerabilities are now patched. Apple’s initial mitigation, released in macOS Sonoma 14.4 as CVE-2024-23285, reduced the maximum impact but left the underlying race conditions unresolved. The remaining issue hasCVE-2026-86933Apple · macOSunresolved. The remaining issue has now been fixed in the latest macOS 27 Golden Gate under CVE-2026-86933. With both issues resolved, we can share a high-level account of the research and its implications
Vendors
Products
macOSThreat Labs discovered two symbolic link race conditions in Apple’s Music.app. On affected versions of macOS, an attacker could chain these vulnerabilities to replace the user’s Transparency, Consent and ControlMusic.appJamf Threat Labs discovered two symbolic link race conditions in Apple’s Music.app. On affected versions of macOS, an attacker could chain these vulnerabilities to replace the user’s Transparency, Consent and Control
