Researchers Show Firmware Rollback Can Cut Windows Hello PIN Guessing to 40 Hours

Summary
TU Berlin researchers found firmware TPM rollback methods that reset failed-PIN counters, reducing four-digit Windows Hello PIN guessing to 40 hours. The reported vulnerabilities remained unfixed when the paper was written.
Key points
- Researchers tested nine computers from 2015 to 2025 and reported that a four-digit Windows Hello PIN could be guessed in 40 hours with their setup, compared with 69 days under normal lockout.
- Firmware TPMs save state, including failed-guess counts, to flash memory; restoring an earlier copy can roll back the counter.
- The researchers demonstrated three bypass paths: voltage glitching to expose a Winbond flash-chip key, blocking counter updates on AMD systems, and restoring old firmware on AMD computers without RPMC flash.
- Their hardware and software setup automated PIN entry, reboots, and restoration of the saved firmware state. The attack requires physical access and hours to days with the computer.
- The researchers said a cracked PIN could also unlock device-bound Windows keys and company single sign-on tied to Windows Hello.
- The paper reported no fixes at the time of writing. Microsoft rated the issue moderate, issued no CVE, and committed to recommending a six-digit Windows Hello PIN minimum.
- The researchers recommend longer PINs; they also advise promptly removing a missing laptop from a Microsoft account and changing passwords for accounts still signed in on it.
Article Details
- Attack Vectors
- Physical access to the computer is required. The attacker opens the device and connects hardware between the processor and flash chip, along with a keyboard-and-screen controller.
- The attack restores a previously copied firmware flash state to reset the firmware TPM's failed-PIN counter. The article reports that AMD computers without RPMC protection accepted an old firmware image, while AMD systems with RPMC were vulnerable to blocking the counter update.
- On Winbond flash chips, briefly disturbing the chip's power supply can reveal the key protecting the RPMC counter, allowing the attacker to fake the counter.
- Software automates PIN guesses at the login screen and reboots the computer to restore the earlier flash state between attempts.
- Defensive Notes
- Use a longer Windows Hello PIN; the researchers recommend at least six digits and preferably eight or more, or adding letters and symbols.
- If using a BitLocker startup PIN, use eight digits or longer; administrators can allow letters through the “Allow enhanced PINs for startup” policy.
- Companies can set a minimum PIN length and require letters through Windows Hello for Business policies.
- If a laptop goes missing, remove it from the Microsoft account, sign out of other accounts on it, and change passwords for accounts that remained signed in.
- The article reports that the firmware and flash-chip vulnerabilities had not been fixed when the paper was written.
MITRE ATT&CK
Vendors
AMDon Windows laptops and desktops that use a firmware TPM, the security chip function built into modern AMD and Intel processors.Intellaptops and desktops that use a firmware TPM, the security chip function built into modern AMD and Intel processors.Microsoft“Normal lockout” assumes the 10-minute wait after too many wrong tries that Microsoft documents; on some laptops the researchers saw 2 hours, which makes guessing without the attack far slower.WinbondWinbond flash chips give away the secret key that protects their counter when the attacker briefly disturbs the chip’s power supply (voltage glitching).
Products
BitLockerA six-digit BitLocker startup PIN, the default minimum, fell in 20 days instead of 19 years.Microsoft WindowsA four-digit Windows Hello PIN is safe only as long as the laptop locks out a thief after a few wrong guesses.PlutonMicrosoft’s own fTPM, Pluton, was affected on AMD systems in the same way as AMD’s.Windows HelloA four-digit Windows Hello PIN is safe only as long as the laptop locks out a thief after a few wrong guesses.
