New York City Council Passes Bill to Ban Surveillance Pricing

Summary
New York City Council passed a bill prohibiting surveillance pricing and restricting related personal-data use. It awaits the mayor’s decision and would take effect one year after becoming law.
Key points
- Introduction 891-A would prohibit using personal data and algorithms to set different prices for different consumers in New York City.
- The bill would also restrict collecting, selling, or sharing personal data to facilitate surveillance pricing; it is awaiting the mayor’s decision.
- The bill preserves qualifying loyalty and rewards discounts and discounts for defined groups, including veterans, seniors, and teachers.
- The article distinguishes surveillance pricing, which uses personal information to differentiate prices, from dynamic pricing based on market conditions.
- FTC staff reported in January 2025 that pricing tools could use detailed behavior, including mouse movements and items left in online shopping carts; the published examples were hypothetical.
Article Details
- Event Type
- New York City Council passed Introduction 891-A, a bill regulating surveillance pricing in consumer transactions; it is awaiting the mayor’s decision.
- Impact
- If enacted, the bill would prohibit using personal data and algorithms to set different prices for consumers in New York City and restrict collecting, selling, or sharing personal data to facilitate surveillance pricing. It preserves qualifying loyalty, rewards, and defined-group discounts. The article also describes privacy risks from extensive data collection, including sensitive inferences and unauthorized disclosure, but reports no specific data breach or other incident.
